Skip to main content

Question #92

How can you possibly decide if you are right about the nature of the universe?

Just askin'

Comments

  1. As for me, I cannot. But I can decide what is more likely than not. I am ok living with uncertainty. It seems to be that nature is designed to always be somewhat unknown, otherwise we wouldn't have any spirit of exploration. Maybe I am certain of this--that life has to be mysterious enough to get us out of the house

    ReplyDelete
  2. To me decision is usually unnecessary or premature. There's usually plenty to go on to choose what to do, without there being any reason or benefit to deciding things about thus-far unattainable levels of reality.

    Now having said that, the scientific method, or more generally, skepticism (defined by me as to suspend judgment in the absence of evidence, and to proceed on the best available theory in the meantime) is a very useful approach, as long as one takes care not to elevate skepticism itself to some fundamental principle.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Or to have so little wonder that skepticism is raised to the level of a fetish. Some people I know instantly snap to disbelief regardless of subject, and call it skepticism.

    I agree that there is a need to leave some stones unturned, because if you don't, then why are you here?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think besides the tangible scientific approach, one can also rely on faith. We don't need to see gravity to know it exists. But how we relate to what we feel and believe (i'll refrain from saying know because one might argue that faith =/= knowledge, but that is a theoretical discussion for another day) is how we relate to the universe. It can almost be likened to the allegory of the cave, which is one of my favorites. In it, the shadows on the wall were the only universe those chained captives knew. Are they wrong? Not for themselves as they believe nothing else.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Question #155

If you had a super power that did not seem immediately useful, like being able to change people's accents from a distance, (say from Brooklyn to French,) what would it be and would you try to use it to fight crime, make money, or just a parlor trick?